- We have to burn down the school to save it? The really nice school?
- Hey Ben: Questions about tax amnesty
- US Rep. John Murtha, June 17, 1932 – February 8, 2010
- Getting Real Answers from Gubernatorial Candidates
- It is always a good thing when our government works well
- Courtfighter: Delaware County Judge Maureen Fitzpatrick A Bigot? You Judge How Often Bigotry Occurs In Media, PA
- We'll Get You Ready for State Budget Release Tuesday
- ONE Praises U.S. Treasury Announcement to Work with International Partners to Relieve Haiti’s Debt
- A giant toxic monster is coming your way OR no rigs before regs!
- We Need Immigration Reform Now! Why Stu Bykofsky got it wrong.
A call for the Mayor and Police Chief to step back on anti-immigrant program
This morning dozens of community members along with several elected officials held a press conference with Pennsylvania Immigration and Citizenship Coalition to encourage the Mayor and Police Chief to reject participation in a federal immigrant tracking program called "Secure Communities."
The program would require police officers to contact ICE (Immigrations and Customs Enforcement which is solely responsible for detention and deportation in immigration matters) as soon as individuals were booked through a federal fingerprinting process. This program is the most recent in a series of ICE programs that make local police the contact point between immigrants and ICE agents.
In other cities, the program has led to serious concerns around selective enforcement and racial profiling, expensive re-direction of personnel resources, and an increase in detention. The increase in detention happens because if there is a match between the federal database and a local individual, ICE will place a detainer on that individual. According to the National Immigration Law Center, ICE frequently does not pick up individuals within a 48 hour time period, "leaving them in detention limbo but often without the means to challenge their unlawful detention."
As Sean and others have eloquently and frequently noted, there's a serious problem in community policing when programs like "Secure Communities" start popping up. In a personal case I was familiar with, a father of a student at a local charter was pulled over for a minor traffic infraction. He was found to have a match in the ICE database, and was eventually hauled off to detention in a West Coast jail, leaving his family bereft. The rest of his family had cleared immigration and he himself was winding through an appeals process, but a basic interaction with a police officer resulted in a real risk for deportation. The family eventually left Philadelphia for New York City, one more loss of tax contributing individuals and an outstanding student in the school system.
In other cases, PICC has noted that the program can sweep up people who could be victims and witnesses for crimes, or are entirely innocent or cleared of charges. It's not like we have a stellar language access system with our local police (although efforts are being made to improve the situation).
More than 700 individuals and dozens of organizations are signed onto a letter to the Mayor, calling upon him to reject the program. Councilman James Kenney, who's been outstanding on this issue, noted that New York City isn't part of this program.
Philadelphia doesn't need it either.
To view and sign the letter, read about it here and contact PICC.


Yeah, maybe 1,000 police layoffs imminent
Lets take cops off of investigating actual criminal investigations and put them on immigration enforcement - because you know Homeland Security doesn't have a big enough budget, don't you know.
I mean immigrants are never the victims of crimes are they? Yeah, this guy had a student visa but I know West African Francophones with touchier immigration status out my way.
Putting up extra barriers for immigrants to help in actual criminal investigations is bad policy for real policing.
-Sean
MrLuigi, my cat, actually only types half as badly as I do.
Thanks for linking to that story Sean
In addition, none of these immigrant-targeting programs originate from municipalities. They're part of a federal political football game to prove that nationally we're "tough on enforcement." It has little to do with actual community needs and concerns.
Currently there are no federal rules stating that participation must be mandatory. Philadelphia has an opportunity to be clear that immigration enforcement should remain a federal issue and leave proper community policing to our communities.
This is appalling. Aside
This is appalling. Aside from the clear civil and human rights issues, Philadelphia is in desperate need of increased population, and benefits tremendously from the economic and cultural contributions of immigrants. This program is totally ass-backwards, morally and practically.
Even more appalling
Even more appalling is that the Mayor wants to stick with this even though Homeland Security has now confirmed that they cannot force municipalities to participate in the program. With no mandate from the Feds the Mayor needs to at least delay involvement in the program until there's full assessment of the costs involved, protective measures are established so innocent people aren't victimized, procedural rules established so residents don't fear the police any more than they already do, and there's a sitdown with the local ICE bureau who's already received national and international attention for their abuse - namely in the violent 2006 deportation of a Philadelphia mother who later miscarried twins after she was denied adequate food, water and medical attention. In the case of immigration I have always felt that this city shared a broad distaste for extreme anti-immigrant sentiment and policy. It would be a shame to see this administration be the first to break with that history.