- We have to burn down the school to save it? The really nice school?
- Hey Ben: Questions about tax amnesty
- US Rep. John Murtha, June 17, 1932 – February 8, 2010
- Getting Real Answers from Gubernatorial Candidates
- It is always a good thing when our government works well
- Courtfighter: Delaware County Judge Maureen Fitzpatrick A Bigot? You Judge How Often Bigotry Occurs In Media, PA
- We'll Get You Ready for State Budget Release Tuesday
- ONE Praises U.S. Treasury Announcement to Work with International Partners to Relieve Haiti’s Debt
- A giant toxic monster is coming your way OR no rigs before regs!
- We Need Immigration Reform Now! Why Stu Bykofsky got it wrong.
Philly Weekly Crushes Trump
Steve Volk, of the Philadelphia Weekly, wrote an absolutely incredible story that comes out today about the moral idiocy of Philadelphia slot parlors, with a particular focus on my “favorite,” Trump Street.
I will quote Volk liberally, but, I strongly encourage everyone to read the article. It is really remarkable, and a great example of why strong, independent local media is not something that is replaceable, not by national newspapers or doofus bloggers like myself.
Volk goes piece by piece though much of the BS that has been thrown our way by the Casino companies in general, and the Trump organization in particular.
Where to begin? Read below.
Well, as Ray mentioned, Trump Street is supposed to provide good jobs for people, right? In that way, the Casino will in some way offset the fact that it is leaching onto a community that really cannot afford to have its money pissed away down one-arm bandits? Well, as Ray also noted, the irony is that to buy itself more land, Trump has greased the wheels for Tastycake, one of the last places with very good jobs in the neighborhood, to bolt.
Well, at least there is no big barrier for people to get these Casino jobs, right? Oh...
There was no public debate before casinos became a reality, and no vote. Those who want to work in our new casinos will have to pay for the privilege. Our cockeyed and corrupt legislators, bloated with power, their feet resting on the illegal immigrants they use as footstools, plan to charge $350 fees to those who want to work as cashiers, change carriers, slots attendants and any other position the state deems gaming-related.
Workers will also be extorted another $350 on an annual basis, purportedly to pay for background checks. Bartenders, food service employees, maintenance workers and other nongaming employees will pay a one-time fee of $60.
And we're just arriving at the scary part.
Yeah, that makes a ton of sense. Out of work people, applying for a low wage job, have tons of cash sitting around to spend anyway.
At least though, they are sacrificing for the good of local businesses, who will benefit from all of this new economic activity:
By the city's own estimates, produced by the Gaming Advisory Task Force, casinos will siphon between 10 percent and 25 percent of their revenue from existing city businesses. That means between $67 million and $187 million in losses to local merchants. These figures, of course, hugely offset the $150 to $220 million in spending the city expects casinos to trigger.
OK, but the City is getting a ton of money for all this, and this money is going into the City coffers, dropping the wage tax a ton, etc. Right?
Casinos will pay the city a 4 percent hosting fee worth approximately $26 to $30 million annually, much of which will be offset by associated costs, like the $11 to $16 million slated for increased policing.
.....
In Philadelphia the wage tax will drop roughly one-tenth of a percentage point for commuters and three-tenths for residents. To the average working stiff making $45,000 a year, the reduction means an annual $120 savings.
The bottom line though is that is all about having a little fun, right? This is not about creating gambling addicts on the streets of Philadelphia? Ohhhhhh, wait, not true…
The industry lured him in with total rewards or “player” cards, which casinos use to track how much a gambler bets. “The more you bet,” says Kearney, “the more ‘rewards' you get—free booze, free food, free hotel rooms. You start feeling like a high roller, like you're getting something for your money.”
State Rep. Paul Clymer has introduced a piece of legislation based on Kearney's comp-card experience, calling for casinos to mail monthly financial statements to those with player cards. “They'll never do it on their own,” says Kearney, “because addicts mean too much to their bottom line.”
.....
“We asked Trump to send monthly statements,” says Wynder. “That's something we're negotiating with them as a means of protecting the community.”
The idea is that gamblers would see how much they're losing and realize they have a problem. The Trump group is predictably cool to the idea. They've told the MCA casino cardholders can obtain financial statements from kiosks inside the casino, and they'll make the information available over the Internet. Kearney says that's not good enough.
.....
Meanwhile, Trump spokesperson Larry Ceisler says sending out statements “raises privacy concerns.”
That argument seems rather flimsy. Credit card companies, for instance, have a nasty habit of sending richly detailed statements to their customers, yet privacy advocates don't make a peep.
……
Kearney thinks the debate itself makes his point. “This fight demonstrates how casinos operate. They won't send statements for one reason: They need gambling addicts.”
Having a slot parlor pretend they don't want gambling addicts is a little like a tobacco company saying they don't want chain smokers. We all know it is a lie, as does Trump. But, couldn't they come up with a better example than privacy concerns? I don't know, it seems like they aren't even trying very hard to shovel us the BS. I mean, if the mail is that unsecure, maybe I better tell my student loan companies, my credit card companies, the phone company and the like that I will need everything hand delivered, or given to me in Morse Code in a secret channel I will set up.
Gambling was, and is, a stupid idea, made stupider with plans to plop down slot parlors in the middle of City neighborhoods. Maybe instead of taking the usual gruel that Harrisburg has dealt out, it is time for some of our local elected officials to pledge to get in front of bulldozers until there are some better resolutions to the myriad of problems that Trump and the rest of the Casinos are going to bring to Philly.


And since Volk covered the di
And since Volk covered the divide and conquer stuff, and we have already mentioned that, I didn't bother. But yeah, that is in there, as well.
What an article.
sorry
sorry to be flip. i do take this rather seriously. i have now unfortunately discovered that you can't delete comments, once posted on YPP!!!!
crappers.
thanks
i am mark . i am a politician. thanks
I can say this, WOW, Volk wro
I can say this, WOW, Volk wrote a great article that people should pay attention to.
Trumping Trump
If we had Elected Officials and Democratic Leaders in Philadelphia who would actually represent us, instead of representing Trump and his ilk -- we might be able to stop this all from happening.
I wish at least ONE elected Philadelphia official would grow a pair and start standing up for us.
"Flimsy Excuse"
I assume DanielUA took great delight in pasting in Volk's opinion of our reasoning for not mailing out those quarterly statements. But I also have to assume he found out from his Father that when Trump came up with another method of notification, His Father said at the negotiating table, "That is even a better idea than mailing the statements" And by the way, Volk as he wrote the piece knew about the more acceptable alternative Hey, its advocacy Journalism, not the New York Times and Steve Volk is entitled to his opinion
Great Article! So what do you really want from Trump?
Great Article!
I'm waiting for MCA to email me their list of demands from Trump ... OOPS ... I mean Community Benefit Agreement (CBA).
Is MCA seeking a CBA or not? How much do you want?!
WWGjr
aw, Larry, like old times
1) Contrary to popular belief, I am not my dad, and have nothing to do with anything about the Trump negotiations. The fact that you are bringing it up is a cute little diversionary ploy when there is an entire article slamming your client. But in the end, it addresses nothing.
2) You said it was a flimsy excuse. Well, it is a flimsy excuse. If you have a different, better solution, great. Glad to hear it. So, why wouldn't you just say that? What is the solution?
If you want to debate substantive issues, or dispute what was in the article, do so. I am all ears. If you want this to be about me, or use race to divide us, or anything else, then nevermind.
The ask
I dunno about you...but if i ran the MCA I wouldn't bother with things like school entrances or money for PennDOT or any of that.
What they should really be asking for exclusive copyright to televised use of the phrase "You're Fired!" (tm)
As someone who uses the phrase "That's Hot!" (tm) all the time and has to tithe money to Paris Hilton, I know how valuable these things can be.
more substantive comments later when i am actually in a serious mood...
hannah
What they want
I don't really know what exactly the MCA is asking for. I guess the first thing they are asking for is for a Casino to not be placed in their neighborhood.
But, just as a very basic example, from the article: a statement to each gambler every month that tells them how much money they have spent. Trump refuses, because they want to insure they can suck every little penny out of Philly's residents before the eviction notices come.
Sorry, Assumed that you and your Dad spoke about this
Trump offered to put customer's gaming activity on-line so people could access it more easily. Your Father and all the negotiators thought that was a better idea. I was just addressing the point you made about me. There are a lot of things in the article I could debate, but we have been down this road so many times and through it all, what is the point? You have your opinion...so does Volk...and so do the residents who support this project for the positives it can bring. There is a split community around Trump, On the River, and probably at every other PA site. It is just the nature of the issue.
Its funny, when a piece is written that agrees with your point of view, it is gospel...but when Tina Moore or someone else from the Inquirer writes a positive Trump piece, then it is trash.
Lets just agree to disagree and let the chips fall where they may. I'm still waiting for you to come down so we can meet each other finally.
it's funny
when someone pays you to say something, you say it and it's gospel. when someone [who is paid nothing disagrees with you] it's trash.
go buy an onion loaf with your money.
--
Albert Yee
http://dragonballyee.blogs.com
well put
Jeez Larry, you sure are sensitive about the Donald.
The Volk article didn't do much, in my opinion, to slander Trump or even paint that negative of a picture of him (despite the cover). It did however provide some pretty straight up, indisuptable facts about gambling addiction.
It also talked, pretty succintly, about the lack of economic development opportunity casinos really provide.
I guess the truth hurts. Which would explain the low-blows...
nah...not really sensitive
Ray:
I think Trump can take care of himself and from what I know of him, the thought is any press is good press. As far as the addiction...that is certainly a concern and the company and industry work very hard to confront it. If you attended any of the community meetings where the Trump Offical whose responsiblity this is spoke, you would have a better idea how seriously they take it....that is why we went to to an on-line real time notification system rather than mailing quarterly...a proposal the community representatives said they liked better.
Economic Development - The Trump plan for for the Budd Site is unique from any other plan around the country. There is a lot of opportunity there and if you study it, you can see what it does and how it can lead to other development. They had a good track record in Gary Indiana which is butressed by a report the state did on them after their first seven years.
Truth is good..all for it. Wish others felt the same way. No low blows coming out of here.