- Council Committee Passed the Freeze
- Carol Campbell Passes Away
- My first trip to the public library
- Fight digital exclusion
- What if half of Philadelphia didn't have roads?
- You know, let's not even worry about the City Commissioners office messing up voter registration processing
- Bold ideas to fix the budget
- Mayor Nutter's Town Hall Meeting Schedule
- City Releases Library Information to City Council
- Size of Philadelphia government?
Casinos and My Neighborhood
Dan and I grew up about 5 blocks from each other in Germantown. We both lived about a mile and a half away from the proposed Casino site in East Falls. And I want to point and make it clear that it is in East Falls, NOT Nicetown. This insisting otherwise is a little insulting, not for the simple fact that it’s a lie, but more so because it almost has this feeling of, well, hey, it’s a poor Black neighborhood, so who cares if they screw it up. I care, but I digress.
The history of East Falls is pretty interesting. It is where Grace Kelly was born and raised. It’s where Frank Sinatra and Ava Gardner were going to get married. (I later found out that the press got wind of it, so they got married in Mt. Airy.) It’s where our Governor calls home and where Arlen Specter used to live, along with a myriad of Judges and other elected officials.
It also used to have a darker side. When I was growing up, Ridge and Midvale was a place that you did not want to be at night. It was a very dangerous and seedy area, with nuisance bars and the like. Now, it’s the opposite, a posh Yuppie enclave for all the people, who, I guess, just don’t feel like hanging out in Manayunk. Its history is the symbol of everything that’s great and everything that’s horrible about our city.
Henry and Roberts is an interesting location. It’s across the street from the now defunct MCP Hospital, which, one night in 1993, saved my father’s life. It’s also near the Tasty Cake factory, which, I’m assuming, will leave the city for good if the Casino comes. It makes you wonder what all those people who carp about the greatness of this when they talk about all the jobs that it will bring. Where were these people when the great community hospital which used to have one of the best Emergency Medicine residencies in the country decided to close its doors? What about all those jobs? Where will these people be when the people at the Tasty Cake factory lose their jobs? They will just complain about the hampered access to Butterscotch Crumpets.
Then, what will come of the neighborhoods? East Falls, and Germantown, where I grew up? First, the traffic will be horrendous. The local entrance to the Roosevelt Expressway and the surrounding streets will be jammed. There are some corners on Fox street that are dangerous intersections now. I can only imagine what they will be like with a casino a block away. Midvale Avenue, the commercial corridor in the area, will see an inordinate amount of traffic. I can only assume that the crime and the nuisance bars will come back, along with more drugs and prostitution. What’s that sound that I here? Oh yeah, it’s the sound of people’s home values plummeting.
I love this site, and the Philadelphia activist community. At the same time, I think that we lose perspective sometimes. I think that we become so interested in the fight that we forget what we are fighting for. As Howard Dean said, it’s the people stupid. It’s not about fighting the good fight or showing truth to power, or this bill or that bill. All that stuff is important, but in the wrong context, it’s basically masturbation.
What it is about is quality of life. I want a place where my parents can retire in peace without worrying about crime and dangerous drivers from all over the state. I want a nice place to raise my kids, if I decide to have them. I want to live in a neighborhood that has a sense of community and history with cultural and economic diversity.
The river is a nice place, and I want to make it a better place as much as everyone else does. One could argue that it’s more important to stop Casinos there than it is to stop them in my area, because it affects, “the city as a whole”. What I think that we should do is make this entire city a great place to live and work. If we start auctioning off our neighborhoods, then we will basically turn into a theme park with surrounding ghettos. We are, after all, Young Philly Politics and not Young Center City Politics.











Thanks, Chuck.
Thanks, Chuck.
I think we need to fight ever
I think we need to fight every battle possible and not give any ground, regardless of where it is. A casino is a casino, whether it is on our riverfront or close to one. Once we divide, well, you know the rest.
That being said. Great post.
Feeling your pain, Charlesdog
In more ways than one. As a resident of Germantown, I'm not looking forward to the increased traffic when I need an alternate route downtown when the River Drives are blocked off, or when I want to go somewhere in North Philly. But even more so, as a resident of Philly, I am angered that my fellow Philadelphians would have their voices effectively silenced by elected officials that they and other Pennsylvanians have elected.
And not to slight those who are actively battling against this very real injustice taking place, I wonder whether Philadelphia's progressives will come together on this issue. In connecting what's happening with the casinos to a topic on another thread - this issue seems to me to be one where we should be saying loud and clear to anyone who wants to obtain elected office in Philly that they need to be out front in leading our neighbors in this fight.
Wilson Goode has said that sausage making is taking place, and that we need to be realistic about compromises, and that we need to be realistic about how much of the decisions being made are in the hands of state, not local, officials. Those all seem like reasonable points, but why aren't all of the mayoral candidates and current and hopeful members of city council publicly out in front on this issue? Can anyone holding or running for office in Philly expect active support from any neighborhood in the city, even those not direcly affected such as Chestnut Hill, Mt. Airy, South Philly, West Philly, Center City, etc., if they aren't speaking publicly on this issue? So far, it seems that the believe that they can. I think it's up to progressives to make it abundantly clear that they can't.
People were very actively motivated to knock on doors to get Casey and other representatives elected. Will we be as actively motivated to deliver a message to current and future elected officials just what we will, and won't, tolerate in our communities?
NIMBY --- appears to be the crying point
I think that the Budd location would be a great site for a casino. My hunch is that it will be a strong positive for the community. Trump has made a pledge to employ neighborhood people. It will spur greater development in that area.
Traffic is an issue that must be addressed no matter where you site a casino. But not by any stretch an insurmountable problem. It will take some traffic engineering and perhaps some modifications\improvements in the infrastructure. But this is an engineering problem.
I have had some strong reservations about the smartness of the whole plan--- that the only way to acheive property tax relief (or wage tax as in the case for native philadelphians) was to bank on casino revenues and profits. My sense is that it was the "easy plan"--- though I wonder if the casinos will really pan out over the long haul.
But given that we are destined to have two casinos in the city--- I personally hope that both are not on the waterfront.
MSL
yes, thanks big time
Thanks for being clear about this and the history is exciting. I learned on the last planphilly.com river walk that the site of the proposed Sugar House casino is the likely location of the Penn Treaty being worked out, not Penn Treaty Park a bit to the north. Regardless, Fishtown is the only neighborhood in Philly that could host two casinos and from day one all five sites were the wrong sites, siting casinos in residential areas makes no sense at all. And bringing casinos to Philly and PA without a referendum is a travesty and can still be corrected at least in Philly. I recommend you check out this article that just came out in the City Paper, http://citypaper.net/articles/2006/11/23/Gaming-the-Casino-Board and join us in Harrisburg on the 11th. If we had just a few more progressive activists helping us with organizing and outreach we could move hundreds of Philadelphians to join us on the 11th and really move towards winning on this critical issue. We need people who like to reach out to others, who are committed to the city and to reform, and can help us with outreach not only in the most impacted communities but in all parts of our city. Thanks and check out www.casinofreephila.org for more info. We plan on really hitting the ground running next week, giving us two full weeks to make this happen. Please consider joining our growing team.