"A Question of Place": An essay on the power of community

With all the news about the library and pool closings and Chinatown’s fight against a Center City slots barn, one thread ties these struggles together – the love of community. These struggles aren’t so much against something as much as they are a powerful statement of the sanctity of sacred spaces in our neighborhoods, of the rare places where the fabric of community is built, where our relationships with one another are fostered and cherished, and where lessons and values are passed onto new generations. Our communities are the heart of civil society.

Recently, Philadelphian Debbie Wei wrote just about the best piece I’ve ever seen on the notion of community and struggle in an essay "A Question of Place" published in Asian Week. Here's an excerpt:

As Philadelphia’s Chinatown fights a proposed casino mere feet from its doorstep, I’ve been thinking a lot these days about why saving Chinatown means so much to me.

Several years ago my youngest son, who studied kung fu and Beijing Opera in Chinatown, told me: "My favorite place to be is Chinatown. I know everyone there. I can walk around and hang out. The guy in the laundromat always gives me candy and everyone knows I’m a lion dancer and the old people all smile at me."

Chinatowns around the country represent an increasingly rare phenomenon. They are communities in the deepest sense: places not only defined by geography but also by memory and relationships. It is why my son would rather buy his candy in Chinatown even though he could get it cheaper at Walmart. When he buys his candy in Chinatown, he knows the clerks, he feels happy to see them and they are happy to see him.

The responsibility that comes with relationships and knowing that there is something bigger than yourself is part of what makes a community live — it is part of what makes us fundamentally human. It isn’t just about a geographic area. It is about emotion, about connection to a place.

It is a deeply moving and personal piece, especially at a time when our struggles seem greatest. As she writes:

"True progress has to do with the human heart and the relationships we build and sustain over time. Our future as a city is not about me and mine, not about rugged individualism, but about collective
responsibility. It’s about what is ours — all of ours.

When you see us in the streets protesting, this is why we fight.

Daily News columnist Ronnie Polaneczy wrote a nice Friday column about this as well. Ronnie was kind enough to reprint Debbie's essay on her blog post. And of course, you can find it at Asian Americans United’s website as well.

A critical point; A beautiful piece of writing

Everyone should read Debbie Wei's essay.

She articulates what every citic activist in this city knows in his or her heart, that in fighting for our communities, we are defending a set of relationships, a connection to place and people, that is far more important to human well being than the size of our paycheck or the balance in our checking account.

Not that economic well being is incompatible with strong communities. There are community based models of development, ones that focus on encouraging sustainable, locally owned businesses owned by people with an organic connection to people who are not just customers but also friends and neighbors.

Gar Alperovitz, who I introduced at a Weaver's Way Coop meeting a year or so ago, has written the best account of how we can revive our country with this model. His most recent book is America Beyond Capitalism.

In the meantime, the secret to building solidarity in this city between neighborhoods is simply to keep asking, would you accept that in your neighborhood? People in this city know what community and neighborhood means and know that when it comes to protecting our communities and neighborhoods, we are all in this together.

So keep asking;

Would you accept a casino down the street?

Would you accept the closing of your library?

If we keep asking these questions we will realize the beautiful vision of Debbie Wei.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Syndicate content